Originally Posted by Eragon
AT&T, Verizon and Apple are out to make money. They really could care less about the average consumer other than how increase ARPU.
The point is they would have the people in contract for an additional year and if next year Apple jumps carriers these people would have to pay an ETF but instead they will be free to move. Now you have a boatload of people who won't upgrade to the 3GS and will more then likely leave when Apple takes the iPhone elsewhere.
The big if and it is a big one is if AT&T hammer out a longer exclusivity with Apple but it seems unlikely seeing that Apple was taking jabs at them at the WWDC.