I may not be returning my white Otterbox to the manufacturer after all. Used it to go to the beach (took some videos and didn't have to worry) and then after going to a friend's house for a 4th of July bbq, it fell out of my pocket and not a scratch on it. Whew!
I think it's too bulky though, but it'll come in handy whenever I go somewhere where I think I'll need the extra protection like the beach! For now, I'm happy with the Candy Shell.