[RichR]

It should not make a difference if you have a iphone v1 or any other at&t phone. To single out the iphone people and only allow them to take advantage of the new iphone prices cant be right. They will either allow anyone with an at&t contract upgrade for the new prices or do what they do with every other phone they sell on their network... Discount the ones eligible or make the ones that are not pay more for the phone. They have been doing that for years. Its not an iphone only club! Now if they allow ANYONE to upgrade for theses new prices no matter what at&t plan you have at any given time, THAT will draw people in and from the look of the specs and terms of the new iphone, this will be needed... IE - activation only in-store, lack of features aticipated, posibility of never being jailbroken like v1.... app store to pay for everything you install, etc...